Sex Matters recently challenged the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) in the High Court over Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) legal guidance on deception as to sex.
“The guidance appears to encourage prosecutors to consider that a trans person’s belief in the authenticity of their identity is a relevant point against charging them in a case of sex by deception.”
In effect they would like to provide a no-consequences “not criminally responsible by virtue of the authenticity of the attacker’s self delusion” yet at the same time any discussion of repathologizing gender dysphoria is bigotry.
If a similar case were made for a killer who “really” believed they were slaying a demon, we would in Canada have that person committed to indeterminate confinement in a secure mental health facility, until their mental health has been restored; why would we not do the same for a delusional rapist?
“The guidance appears to encourage prosecutors to consider that a trans person’s belief in the authenticity of their identity is a relevant point against charging them in a case of sex by deception.”
In effect they would like to provide a no-consequences “not criminally responsible by virtue of the authenticity of the attacker’s self delusion” yet at the same time any discussion of repathologizing gender dysphoria is bigotry.
If a similar case were made for a killer who “really” believed they were slaying a demon, we would in Canada have that person committed to indeterminate confinement in a secure mental health facility, until their mental health has been restored; why would we not do the same for a delusional rapist?